If you disagree with OATH’s decision, you can appeal. In most cases, you must pay the fine before you can appeal. If you win your appeal, you’ll be issued a refund.
You can file an appeal online or by mail.
OATH must receive your appeal request within 30 days of the date of the decision or within 35 days of the mailing date if the decision was mailed to you. You must also provide a copy of your appeal to the Agency that issued the summons.
Learn more about appeals.
City Agency Appeals
If you win your case and the violation is dismissed after the hearing is held, the City enforcement Agency that prosecuted the case has the right to appeal that decision.
The Agency must notify you and give you a chance to respond to their appeal. Responses must be submitted by mail or online before the deadline. You can schedule an appointment with the OATH Help Center to get help with filing a response to the City’s appeal.